| Year | Name | Team | Golden Sombreros | Platinum Sombreros |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Tyler O'Neill | Boston Red Sox | May 15 vs TB May 24 vs MIL June 14 vs NYY July 11 vs OAK August 18 @ BAL Sept. 20 vs MIN |
None |
| 2025 | Rafael Devers | Boston Red Sox/ San Francisco Giants |
Mar. 28 BOS@TEX June 30 SF@ARI August 1 @ NYM August 15 vs TB Sept. 19 @ SD |
None |